Dog Training Collar Buying Guide

Dog Collar GPS

When I first started training dogs, I swore that I would never get a shock collar to train them with. But after I stumbled across some research on them I actually changed my mind. Shock collars – or training collars as I prefer to call them – are not inhumane at all, any more than a dog whistle or a clicker device is.

But that’s only true if you choose the right training collar. Electronic dog training collars vary considerably from one to another. Some of them I would never use on my dog and others I have no problem with. The breed, size and personality of the dog need to be taken into consideration as well.

With that said, here are the dog training collars that I am recommending, with price ranges that will fit anyone’s budget.

Best Dog Training Collar Over $25

Reading dog training collars reviews and carefully looking at the specifications on the best rated dog training collars is vital to choosing the right ones. Here are some of the best remote dog training collars including waterproof dog training collars and much more.

*Notice: On mobile devices, scroll right to see entire table

The Remote-Controlled Dog Shock Collar By PetTech

  • Dog Size: 10-100 pounds
  • Color(s): Black Only
  • Collar Weight: 9.8 ounces
  • ​Range: 400 Yards
  • Levels: 0-100
  • Remote: LED, easy-to-push buttons
  • ​Channels: 2
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • Dimensions: 7.5 x 5.9 x 1.8 inches
  • Additional Features: Can purchase additional collar for same remote.
The Remote Controlled Dog Shock Collar

What I Like

This isn’t the greatest collar on the market but it is a good one. One of the things that I really like about it is the fact that you can customize your levels so precisely.

When you are using training collars, sometimes you find yourself right in between two settings – such as two and three on a seven level collar – where two is too little and three is too much. You usually end up going with too little because your love your dog. This collar has adjustable settings from 0 to 100 so you can get the perfect amount of vibration.

What I Dislike

The problem with this collar is that the setting goes up to high. This isn’t a problem for the conscientious dog owner, but some people may try to set it above 50, particularly if they have a large dog, and that is too high for any dog.

Even the lower settings can be too intense for some smaller dogs. This isn’t really a problem with the collar; more of an extra feature. Still, there is no reason to jack the voltage above 50 and you should never, ever use it near 100.

The Bottom Line

For the price, and the customization you get, it’s actually a really good deal. Just don’t use it on the higher settings.

Red Check Latest Prices Button

Fiddo Electric Dog Collar 330 Yards Remote Dog Training E-collar

  • Dog Size: 15-100 pounds
  • Color(s): Black Only
  • Collar Weight: 8 ounces
  • ​Range: 330 Yards
  • Levels: 0-100
  • Remote: LED, easy-to-push buttons
  • ​Channels: 2
  • ​Warranty: Not listed
  • Dimensions: 8 x 6.5 x 2 inches
  • Additional Features: Can purchase additional collar for same remote. Has additional training types

What I Like

I really love this collar because it gives pet owners a major array of choices when it comes to how they want to train their pets. Some people think that using a shock collar is inhumane and they don’t want to try it.

Later on, after they do some research, they find out that the collar is actually pretty effective and recommended by breeders and vets. That was my situation. But it was too late, and I had already purchased several alternatives.

That’s the difference with this unit. It gives you four choices for stimulation to make your training totally personalized. You can set it to shock if you like, or you can use settings like sound (beeping) lights and even a gentle vibration.

What I Dislike

Again, just like the previous PetTech collar, I don’t like the fact that this goes all the way up to 100 and the very most you will be able to handle (as a human being) is probably 60. There is no good reason to have the power option that high.

The Bottom Line

Again yes, it is a solid purchase, but just be careful what setting you use it at.

Red Check Latest Prices Button

Slicemall Waterproof And Rechargeable Remote Electric Dog Training Collar

  • Dog Size: Unknown
  • Color(s): Black Only
  • Collar Weight: 8.8 ounces
  • ​Range: 500 Yards
  • ​Levels: 0-100
  • Remote: LED, easy-to-push buttons
  • Channels: 1
  • Warranty: Not specified
  • Dimensions: Unknown
  • Additional Features: Waterproof, energy-saving design.

What I Like

I really like how long the range is on this collar. This is one of the few out there that has a range of 500 yards, which is quite a great distance. This is also a waterproof collar, which means that you can take your dog out to the pool or the lake and do training, without having to worry about electric shock affecting their health because of the moisture.

This isn’t the best collar on the market but it certainly is one of the best. I like the fact that every button here has a different function so you are sure not to get anything mixed up. This can be a problem on some remotes. Finally, I like the fact that it offers both vibration and shock.

What I Dislike

You have heard me talk before about how I hate collars that give you far more power than you need. Are they expecting you to have to use this collar to train a Stegosaurus? There is no reason that you need to use this device above 50 or 60 (out of a 100 point setting). I do like the adjustability down to the single point, but I don’t want people to have that much power to hurt their pets.

The Bottom Line

If you need a waterproof training collar, this is your guy. The fact that it is waterproof does make me feel a little more comfortable with the higher settings (if it was too high they couldn’t claim it waterproof) so I will recommend it.

Red Check Latest Prices Button

Naturepets No Bark Collar - No Harm Shock Dog Control

  • Dog Size: Seems to be medium to large dogs
  • Color(s): Black Only
  • Collar Weight: 2.4 ounces
  • Range: Doesn’t Specify
  • Levels: 1-7
  • Remote: LED, easy-to-push buttons
  • ​Channels: 2
  • ​Warranty: Unknown
  • ​Dimensions: 3.3 x 3.1 x 1.8 Inches
  • Additional Features: Added protection with auto-shut-off so that your dog doesn’t get too many shocks.

What I Like

I really like how this collar is designed. The construction is terrific and the satisfaction is guaranteed, which you don’t find with all of the collars out there. It isn’t quite clear what the range is on this thing, because the manufacturer’s information doesn’t say, but it is very likely an acceptable 300-400 yards.

I also like the fact that this will fit on almost any dog from about 15 pounds all the way to 120 pounds. Finally, I like the fact that it includes both long electrodes and short electrodes to allow for the different breeds of dogs out there.

What I Dislike

This unit progresses through levels as your dog continues to bark. There are seven different levels and that is where I run into a problem with this unit. The levels increase the more that your dog barks, which means that it will run up to seven levels eventually.

I don’t think that’s necessary. I would prefer it if I could test out the collar myself and then have a cutoff point. The higher levels may be extremely uncomfortable to some dogs, and while that is the point, I think that I would like to choose that level for my pet, since I know him the best.

The Bottom Line

There are a lot of good features and if you have dog that you have tried everything to get him or her to stop barking, this might be a great collar for you. If you are just looking for a training collar, there are probably some better ones on this list.

Red Check Latest Prices Button

Conclusion

So, these are some of the dog collars that are available over $25. The thing about this category of dog collar is that it is mostly made up of electronic and highly recommended dog collars. In the next category, the under $25 category, there are collars that work differently without any electronics at all, and they are priced to reflect that.

So, your choice as to how much money to spend on a dog collar will depend upon what your personal preference for one is, and what your dog can handle. If you find that the budget collars listed below do not do the trick for your dog, you might want to consider one of the collars listed above.

Best Dog Training Collars Under $25

If you are on a limited budget, you might want to consider a dog training collar at a lower price point. In general, these will not have as many features as their more expensive counterparts and they might be made out of cheaper materials in some cases.

*Notice: On mobile devices, scroll right to see entire table

But you can actually get some pretty great dog collars for under $25. You just have to make sure that they are going to be strong enough for your dog and that you aren’t getting something that is unsafe.

Here are some of the best dog training collars for those on a budget.

Star Mark Pro-Training Dog Collar

  • Dog Size: 21” collar – fits larger dogs – Offers small and extra-large sizes as well.
  • Color(s): Black Only
  • Collar Weight: 1 Pound
  • Range: N/A
  • Levels: N/A
  • Remote: N/A
  • ​Channels: N/A
  • Warranty: Not specified
  • Dimensions: 8 x 3 x 11 inches
  • Additional Features: Created by dog experts at Triple Crown Dog Academy

What I Like

What I like about this collar is that it was created by expert trainers at the Triple Crown Dog Academy, which is a well-respected and recognized training institute. That means that it is probably very human for your dog. It used plastic tines instead of shocks, vibrations or sounds to get your dog’s attention.

However, these are specifically designed to be as gentle as possible. I really like the way that this is designed and I think that it would be effective when training. I also really like the price. This unit was made to work on a budget and the price is pretty low, considering the quality that went into it.

Finally, I really like the fact that this collar allows you to remove the plastic teeth so that you can make it adjustable for just about any dog. This is a very useful feature.

What I Dislike

What I don’t particularly like is the fact that it isn’t always effective. The strength of the electronic or vibrating collars is that you can adjust it when you need to so that your dog that isn’t responding to the lower levels will have to deal with the higher levels.

This has no higher levels. If your dog doesn’t respond to the collar then you are just stuck and you have to buy another one. This seems a little like a waste of money to me.

The Bottom Line

So, should you get this collar? Why not? The price makes it affordable for just about everyone and if it works then you will have saved a lot of money on a shock or vibration collar.

Red Check Latest Prices Button

Petrainer PET998DRB Dog Training Collar

  • Dog Size: 15 pounds or Larger
  • Color(s): Black Only
  • Collar Weight: 9.6 ounces
  • Range: 330 Yards
  • Levels: 0-100
  • Remote: LED, easy-to-push buttons
  • ​Channels: 2
  • Warranty: 1 Year Replacement Warranty
  • ​Dimensions: 7.6 x 1.8 x 6 inches
  • Additional Features: 3 Training Stimulation Types, Can Purchase Either One or Two

What I Like

I like this collar, which colleagues and friends will be surprised by, because I usually abhor collars like this. Let me explain before you start pointing your finger and calling me a hypocrite.

These collars (the ones with plastic or metal spikes) are usually designed by some dog collar manufacturer who doesn’t know the first thing about training dogs.

These collars are intended to cause pain to punish dogs who are acting up and I don’t agree with that philosophy of training. I think that all you need to do is get a dog’s attention if you want to correct their behavior.

All of that being said, I will go ahead and give this product a thumbs up; this is mostly because I can respect the institution that designed and released the model that this collar was based off of – Triple Crown Dog Training. I believe it was mentioned earlier if you want to take a look.

What I Dislike

Okay, so as I said, I don’t usually recommend collars like this. I don’t like it when sharp things poke my dog, even if it is supposed to be an attention-getting action that will help training.

However, these spikes were designed to be very gentle. From what I have been able to get based upon the research I have conducted, is that these spikes are as gentle as the vibration setting on some of the multi-function collars we have reviewed here.

The Bottom Line

You have probably already figured out that I am going to recommend this collar. It is not my style but it is perfectly humane and will work for a lot of dogs.

Red Check Latest Prices Button

Pet Supply Imports Herm Sprenger Chrome Plated Training Collar

  • Dog Size: Small to Medium
  • Color(s): Blue Only
  • Collar Weight: 0.8 ounces
  • Range: N/A
  • Levels: N/A
  • Remote: N/A
  • ​Channels: N/A
  • ​Warranty: Limited
  • ​Dimensions: 7.5 x 5.9 x 1.8 inches
  • Additional Features: None
Pet Supply Imports Herm Sprenger

What I Like

Okay, so I will tell you that I can appreciate that this collar is chrome-plated, which means that is does have some strength and durability to it. This is important when it comes to dog training collars because your dogs will usually put them through the wringer.

I also like the fact that the price is fairly low and most of the people that have tried this collar out have been pleased with the results.

What I Dislike

However, there are a lot more things that I dislike about this product. First of all, it looks just like a medieval torture device. I don’t like the look of it, and I don’t like the idea of putting it around my dog’s neck.

I don’t have a problem with most training collars that work like this, but this seems designed to punish the dog rather than correct their behavior – it looks as if it would actually hurt if you pulled on the leash and might even be able to draw blood if enough pressure was applied.

It says that it is recommended by trainers, but that just means that it is effective and I would be a lot more comfortable if there was a disclaimer that said it was recommended by veterinarians as well.

The Bottom Line

I cannot recommend this collar in good faith. I could be wrong about it, but I would rather go with a training collar that I am 100% is humane and will not cause my dog undue pain.

There are so many out there that really are recommended by trainers and vets (including collars with a very similar corrective mechanism to this) that there is no reason to go with something that looks so rough on your pup.

Red Check Latest Prices Button

Esky Rainproof Rechargeable LCD Shock Control Pet Dog Training Collar

  • Dog Size: 30+ Pounds
  • Color(s): Blue, Orange
  • Collar Weight: 10.7 ounces
  • Range: Does not Specify
  • Remote: LED, easy-to-push buttons
  • Channels: 1
  • Warranty: 1 Year Replacement Warranty
  • Dimensions: 7.5 x 5.7 x 1.8 inches
  • Additional Features: 3 Types of Stimulation, Water Resistant

What I Like

The first thing that I will mention that I really like about this dog collar is that it is rainproof. This is something that so few of the electronic dog collars on the market fail to address, but something that is so important to dogs and dog owners in wet climates. This collar will work in the rain just like it works in the sun.

I also like the fact that it seems so rugged. There are lots of collars out there that don’t seem like they would make it through a lot of rough treatment but everything from the collar itself to the remote seems to be made of really durable materials. In addition, the remote is orange instead of black, which means that there is less chance of me putting it down and not being able to find it again.

In addition, I like the fact that it comes with some trainer recommendations and a warranty, and I like the fact that you can get it for two dogs (same remote, two different collars) for just a few dollars more.

What I Dislike

There really isn’t much that I dislike about this product. The only thing that I would mention is that I would prefer that the shock levels not go up as high as they do.

The Bottom Line

Buy it, but be careful using it. Also, get both collars. Even if you only have one dog you might need a backup.

Red Check Latest Prices Button

KONG Cloud E-Collar For Cats And Dogs

  • Dog Size: XS, S, M, L, XL
  • Color(s): Blue Only
  • Collar Weight: 8 ounces
  • Range: N/A
  • Levels: N/A
  • Remote: N/A
  • ​Channels: N/A
  • ​Warranty: Not Specified
  • Dimensions: 15 x 0.5 x 15 inches
  • Additional Features: Can be used for medical purposes

What I Like

This collar has a lot of good stuff that I can get behind. First of all, this collar can be used for training, but is mostly intended for you to use it while your pet is injured. What this means to me – as a pet owner – is that the collar is meant to be comfortable and not cause my dog any pain.

I also like the fact that it comes in five different sizes so you can get the perfect one for your pet. The collar is inflatable and comfortable and I like that as well.

What I Dislike

The thing is, this isn’t exactly made to be a training collar. You can use it as a training collar if you want, but what it is actually best for is when your dog is recovering from some injury and needs to avoid a lot of head or neck movement.

It doesn’t interfere with your dog’s peripheral vision and the price is pretty great, but my issue with this collar is that it doesn’t make training any easier really.

The Bottom Line

I can’t really recommend this collar when there are so many others on this list that are good training collars. You need something that provides feedback to your dog whenever behavior correction is necessary and I think this collar makes that difficult.

Red Check Latest Prices Button

Rogz Utility Large 3/4-Inch Reflective Fanbelt Dog Collar

  • Dog Size: Medium to Large Dogs
  • Color(s): Black, Blue, Chocolate, Lime, Orange, Pink, Purple, Red, Turquoise, Yellow
  • Collar Weight: 1.6 ounces
  • Range: N/A
  • Levels: N/A
  • Remote: N/A
  • ​Channels: N/A
  • ​Warranty: 1 Year for Manufacturer Defects Only
  • Dimensions: 23.2 x 1.4 x 0.1 Inches
  • Additional Features: None

What I Like

There are so many great things about this collar that it is difficult to know where to begin. Let’s start with the colors. Unlike most of the other collars out there, you actually get a choice, so you can get a collar that reflects your – or your dog’s – personality.

I also think the price is unbeatable. This is one of the lowest priced collars on this list and it is inexpensive enough to get several of them if you like more than one color. The price is one of the biggest advantages that this has over the competition.

In addition, I really like the fact that it uses pressure rather than plastic (or metal) spikes to correct behavior. This is a very humane collar that won’t hurt your dog. It’s also worth noting that they have designed it specifically so that your dog won’t be able to take it off.

What I Dislike

The only real problem that I have with this collar is that it might not be effective for some dogs. While this says that is fits medium to large dogs, I think that some animals are not going to respond to the pressure and may need more correction than this collar offers. That being said, it is inexpensive enough to try it out and see if it works. If it doesn’t, then you can always move onto a collar that provides better feedback.

The Bottom Line

I definitely recommend this collar. I think it is a good buy and very humane. The price is terrific and having a choice of what color to get really helps sell this collar to me as well.

Red Check Latest Prices Button

Conclusion

As you have seen here, some of the lower priced collars do not have anything fancy except for specially designed spikes that you are able to use whenever your dog is on the leash. The problem with these collars is that you have no option for corrective behavior when your dog is off the leash.

PetTech Remote Controlled Dog Training Collar on a Golden Retrievers Neck

For example, let’s say that you were trying to train your dog to stay in your yard. You could use a shock collar and an invisible fence, but you are going to have to pay a lot more for it. You could also go with a training collar that does shock or vibration and then activate it when your dog crosses the property line.

With most of these collars, you have no option for training unless they are on the leash. I think this might present a problem for serious trainers, but since they are so inexpensive, there is no reason not to try one before you move on to the higher-priced collars.

Leave a Comment: